Poisoning is a worldwide problem, but the major effects are felt in the developing world. At least 250,000 to 350,000 people die every year from acute pesticide poisoning,72 and an estimated 20,000 to 94,000 humans die each year from snake bites,97 the vast majority of whom lives in rural farming areas of lower and middle income countries. Hundreds of thousands of people are affected by groundwater arsenic contamination in Bangladesh and India,149 and outbreaks of poisoning from contaminated food40 and environmental pollution from poorly regulated industrial activity49,135 affect whole communities throughout the developing world.
The resources for dealing with these problems are limited in many countries. Public health education about poisons and infrastructure limiting access and exposure to the most highly toxic chemicals are practically absent in much of the developing world. Access to medical care is often limited for financial, cultural, and geographic reasons. Medical toxicology is frequently not a recognized specialty and patients are evaluated by general physicians with little training—although often with great experience. Diagnostic facilities are few, effective treatment options even more rare. Where antidotes exist, there is rarely enough knowledge or experience to use them effectively.30 Intensive care beds for invasive monitoring and long-term ventilation are scarce. This chapter outlines some of the major poisoning risks and challenges for medical toxicology in the developing world.
POISONING AND THE GLOBAL BURDEN OF DISEASE
The World Health Organization (WHO) has ranked injury, including poisoning, among the top 15 causes of death worldwide for persons aged 5 to 44 years.114,174 Recent reanalysis of data from the Global Burden of Disease project estimated that acute and chronic exposure to chemicals caused over 4.9 million deaths and 86 million disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) worldwide in 2004—more than cancer, sexually transmitted diseases, or diabetes.135,179 Children younger than 15 years of age bore more than one half of this burden.
Tremendous regional disparities in the health impact of poisoning are apparent. The global mortality burden from poisoning is disproportionately shouldered by lower and middle income countries. Overall, as much as 75% or more of all poisoning related deaths occur in the developing world,81 and an estimated 95% of children who die each year from acute poisoning live in low- and middle-income countries.174 Children living in Sub-Saharan Africa are at highest risk, with an estimated annual mortality rate of four children per 100,000 population. This is double the global average and higher than that in any other region.142
These figures are striking, yet most likely underestimate the contribution of poisoning to the global burden of disease and disability. Much of the existing data on poisoning epidemiology from lower income countries reflects the experience in larger hospital centers. By contrast, most of the population lives in rural areas, and many patients with poisoning may never reach such facilities for a variety of financial, cultural, or geographic reasons. For example, logistical difficulty with accessing health care facilities was responsible in part for the high mortality from snakebite noted in one community-based study in Nepal.146 Social or economic barriers often contribute to “healer shopping” within traditional or spiritual systems, with allopathic medical care delayed or avoided in many African countries.52,86,128
Unintentional poisoning risks from occupational, environmental, food, or medication sources may also be poorly recognized in communities, or by health care workers.123 The diagnosis of poisoning may not be suspected if a clear history of exposure is not given, because symptoms can mimic infectious or other processes and few medical centers have ready access to laboratory tests for specific poisons. When poisoning is suspect, many countries lack detailed injury surveillance systems or other standardized reporting mechanisms. The WHO has undertaken several initiatives to improve global poisoning surveillance, including support for poison center (PC) development in under represented regions worldwide, and the international efforts of the IPCS/INTOX programs to harmonize data collection and reporting terminology represent an important step toward this goal. However, the interpretation of PC data as evidence of epidemiologic trends must be approached with some caution (Chap. 136).
COMMON XENOBIOTICS AND PATTERNS OF POISONING
Agents commonly involved in acute poisoning differ substantially between communities, both within and among countries. For example, a comparison of poisoning cases seen at a major public teaching hospital in New York City with two large rural hospitals in Sri Lanka found striking differences in the classes of xenobiotics involved. A total of 70% of the patients in New York City were poisoned with pharmaceuticals, and 90% of patients in the Sri Lankan cohort were poisoned with nonpharmaceuticals, primarily pesticides and botanicals, such as yellow oleander, with a 10 times higher case fatality rate.81 A study comparing poisoning epidemiology in district (rural) and regional (urban) hospitals in Zimbabwe found that poisoning from pesticides was equally common in both settings, but animal envenomation was seen nearly twice as often at the district facilities compared to regional centers, and poisoning with pharmaceuticals was a problem seen uniquely at the regional hospital.156
Understanding the local patterns and specific risks for poisoning in particular communities is of critical importance since it provides an evidence base for designing and prioritizing strategies to prevent or limit harm. This section reviews some of the more common xenobiotics implicated in poisoning in developing countries worldwide.
A systematic review suggested that at least 250,000—but more likely 350,000—deaths occur each year from acute pesticide self-poisoning around the world.72 The WHO now considers pesticide poisoning to be the single most important means of suicide, accounting for more than one-third of all suicides worldwide.25 Most of these deaths occur in Asia, particularly in China and India.72 The annual number of deaths from occupational or unintentional pesticide poisoning is unknown but was estimated 20 years ago at 20,000.90
While many classes of pesticides are implicated (Chap. 113), organic phosphorous (OP) pesticides appear to be responsible for the majority of pesticide-related deaths in the developing world.56 Deliberate self-poisoning with OP pesticides puts a high cost on the health care system. In one study examining the experience in Sri Lanka, OP pesticide poisoning was responsible for 943 of 2559 (36%) admissions to a secondary hospital for poisoning.60 The case fatality for OP poisoning was 21%, and pesticide poisoned patients occupied 41% of all medical intensive care beds. Similar situations have been reported from across the world.56 In all likelihood, such studies underestimate the mortality associated with intentional pesticide ingestion as most are hospital based and do not include patients who die prior to hospital presentation.2
Factors contributing to the high mortality of self-poisoning with pesticides in the developing world include the intrinsic lethality of many pesticides, and health care systems that are poorly prepared to handle such critically ill patients (Table 137–1). Pesticides are often easily available in highly concentrated preparations in rural communities throughout the developing world. The ease of drinking liquid pesticides is also a factor facilitating massive intentional ingestions, as are inadequate pesticide storage systems.99 Outbreaks of unintentional poisoning from contaminated flour or old pesticide containers used to store food still occur in rural areas.54 The extraordinarily high human, economic, and social costs of pesticide-related mortality worldwide reinforce the importance of developing simple, economical, and evidence based strategies specifically designed to care for acutely poisoned patients in resource limited environments.26,32
TABLE 137–1.Factors Contributing to High Mortality from Self Poisoning with Pesticides in the Developing World |Favorite Table|Download (.pdf) TABLE 137–1. Factors Contributing to High Mortality from Self Poisoning with Pesticides in the Developing World
Ease of access to pesticides in rural, agrarian households
Poor storage practices
Inadequate labeling of lethal pesticide products
High potency of pesticides
Lack of evidence based practice guidelines appropriate for resource poor areas
Lack of clear guidelines
Distance from and time to health care facilities and resources available at health care facilities
Envenomation by snakes and other animals represents another significant cause of morbidity and mortality in the developing world. Few countries mandate the reporting of animal bites, making it difficult to estimate global incidence, severity, and outcome. Current data estimates that about 20,000 to 94,000 deaths occur globally each year from snakebite.97 The vast majority of deaths and serious envenomations occur in the developing world, with less than 100 snakebite deaths per year estimated to occur in Europe, the United States, Canada, and Australia combined.42,97
Because most rural people in the developing world may first consult traditional healers, hospital based studies of mortality and morbidity associated with snakebites likely underestimate the scope of the problem.42,150 For example, a study of rural Philippine rice farmers found that only 8% of cobra (Naja philippinensis) bite victims reached a hospital in the 1980s.170 However, changes in treatment seeking can occur. Studies over the last decade in Sri Lanka have shown that patients have started going to the hospital rapidly after common krait (Bungarus caeruleus) snakebite, bypassing traditional healers.103 A study in Ghana found that the incidence of snakebite victims at a district hospital increased significantly after the introduction of a new treatment protocol, possibly reflecting increased confidence in the ability of the health care system to manage these cases.168
Snakebites are most commonly occupational hazards in the rural tropics. Victims are just as likely to be women as men, reflecting rural farming practices. Working in large plantations and subsistence farms places rural people in frequent contact with venomous snakes. With simultaneous changes in global climate and expansion of human settlements, it is likely that the range of venomous snakes will enlarge to include urban areas and regions previously considered too temperate to support them.82,121 Snakebites from members of the Elapidae and Viperidae families are responsible for the majority of deaths worldwide, although several other families are also medically important (Colubridae and Atractaspididae species, in particular; Chap. 122 and Special Considerations: SC8).169,172
The burden of snake envenomation on local resources can be substantial. During the rainy season in Benin, snakebites account for up to 20% of all hospital admissions, with an estimated case fatality rate of 3% to 6%.43 In this region, the annual incidence of snake envenomation ranges from 200 to 100,000 in rural villagers to 1300 to 100,000 in sugar cane plantation workers.43 One study conducted in Nigeria in the late 1970s noted an incidence of 497 per 100,000 and a 12% case fatality (primarily due to envenomation by the carpet viper, Echis occelatus).136
After snakebites, the second most common cause of mortality and morbidity from venomous animals is scorpion stings88,169 (Chap. 118). Medically important scorpion species are widely distributed throughout the tropics, being particularly common causes of morbidity in North Africa, Mexico, India, and Brazil.44 The total number of medically significant scorpion stings that occurs annually is unknown; a recent review estimated 1.2 million stings, leading to more than 3250 deaths (case fatality 0.27%).44 Other venomous insects, such as Arachnida (spiders) and Hymenoptera (bees, ants, and wasps), are rarely sources of significant mortality on a global scale88 (Chap. 118).
Herbal and Traditional Medicines
The use of traditional medicine (TM) to treat or prevent health problems is widespread. The WHO estimates that around 80% of the world’s population consults traditional healers regularly.177 Frequently cited reasons for this preference or reliance on TM include financial considerations, sociocultural preferences, beliefs about the relative safety and efficacy of TM compared to allopathic medicines, and mistrust or relative inaccessibility of doctors.86,128 Traditional practitioners still greatly outnumber medical professionals in many regions. For example, in 2004 there was one traditional healer but only 0.04 physicians per 500 inhabitants in Mali.71
Although TM also encompasses a variety of spiritual, religious, or physical manipulation therapies, it often includes administration of “herbal” remedies (muti) either orally or via enema. These are typically prepared using a combination of aqueous plant materials, sometimes mixed with insect or other animal parts, metallic salts, or both. While traditional medicinal preparations have usually been tested by generations of practitioners and the concentrations of active ingredients are generally low, both intentional and unintentional poisonings are common.38,94,153,157 In a 2-year retrospective review of acutely poisoned patients from South Africa, TM was the second most common cause of admission (15.8% of cases) and had the highest mortality rate (15.2%), accounting for over half of all deaths in the series.167 TM was the most common cause of admission (23% of cases) for acute poisoning in another 10-year retrospective review of cases from Zimbabwe, with a 6% mortality rate.95
The specific chemical constituents responsible for TM poisoning may vary widely between geographic and cultural areas. Laboratory analysis and ethnopharmacologic surveys in a number of countries have begun to elucidate some of the chemical constituents of commonly prescribed recipes. Interestingly, a review of 41 autopsies in South Africa for which the causative agent was presumed to be an herbal medicine found that cardiac glycosides were present in 44% of cases.109 Adulterants are also implicated in poisoning from TM formulations. For example, these are common in traditional Ayurvedic medicines (particularly heavy metals63 and corticosteroids75) and Asian medicines (particularly synthetic pharmaceuticals and heavy metals36 Chap. 45). A Taiwanese study of 2609 samples found that 23% were adulterated with pharmaceutical products such as caffeine, NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and diuretics.84
In many lower income countries, pharmaceuticals are relatively uncommon causes of acute poisoning. However, the incidence appears to be rising in conjunction with larger global demographic shifts toward increased urbanization and industrialization. Access to a wider array of medications is relatively greater among urban dwellers than in rural ones, and more people in urban communities may have the financial means to buy them. In a retrospective review of poisoning cases admitted to urban versus rural health centers in Zimbabwe, poisoning with pharmaceuticals was uniquely seen at the urban facilities, accounting for more than 15% of poisoning cases at regional hospitals surveyed and none of the cases presenting for care at the district level.156 The relative importance of pharmaceuticals in global poisoning trends is likely to continue over the next decades as the number of therapeutic drugs available for use in lower income countries expands, and more and more societies shift toward a “dual burden of disease” pattern, including chronic illnesses that require long-term drug therapy.21,120
The pharmacopeia available in low-income countries is often more restricted than in higher income countries, and this is reflected in the types of medications implicated in acute poisoning cases. The most common xenobiotics seen in the developing world are those used to treat tropical diseases. For example, self-poisoning with the antimalarial chloroquine (Chap. 59) has been widely reported in Sub-Saharan Africa,20,27,116,137 although this medication is now rarely used so the incidence may soon decrease. Intentional and unintentional poisoning with the leprosy drug dapsone, as well as the tuberculosis drug isoniazid (Chap. 58), are also well reported.132,158,159,165
Criminal poisoning of commuters to facilitate robbery is a common problem across South Asia.89,117,133 In the 1970s and 1980s, drinks containing extracts of Datura stramonium were given to unsuspecting commuters, resulting in anticholinergic poisoning.98 Practice has changed recently and benzodiazepines are now more commonly given for this purpose.108 As many as 300 people are admitted unconscious with this problem to a single university medical unit in Dhaka each year.108
A more general issue of toxicologic concern is the prevalence of poor-quality medicines in use worldwide. Although data estimating the extent of the problem and its impact on health are limited, recent estimates suggest that more than one-third of all medicines on sale in Southeast Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa are substandard or counterfeit.23,118,119 The major problem with these medications is an absence or subtherapeutic concentration of active ingredient, leading to treatment failures and an increase in drug-resistant pathogens where antimicrobials are involved. However, substandard medications may sometimes contain more active ingredient than stated, leading to adverse drug effects,161 or contain harmful adulterants or contaminants.
Epidemic poisonings from such poor quality medicines underscore the dangers of inadequate regulation and oversight of pharmaceutical manufacture and sales. Recent examples include the deaths of more than 120 patients in Karachi from exposure to a batch of isosorbide mononitrate contaminated with pyrimethamine,15 the hospitalization of more than 50,000 infants in China with melamine poisoning from adulterated formula,87 and the numerous epidemics of diethylene glycol poisoning in multiple countries over the past few decades from contaminated glycerine, paracetamol syrups, cough syrups, toothpastes, teething mixtures, and other medications.22,79,125,127,140,148
Household Products and Chemicals
Poisoning with common household products, such as fuels, cleansing products, rat poisons, insecticides, body care products, and cosmetics, is a global problem. This general category of diverse xenobiotics is consistently implicated as a significant source of unintentional childhood poisoning worldwide. The PC movement that began in the 1950s in North America grew out of an increasing recognition of the child health risks associated with exploratory household poison ingestions. Household chemicals are a similarly well recognized risk for unintentional childhood poisoning in Sub-Saharan Africa, accounting for up to 80% of all pediatric admissions for poisoning.21,41,45,96,126 Internationally, the specific risks are remarkably consistent, including age younger than 6 years (with toddlers younger than 3 years of age most affected), male sex, low socioeconomic status, and unsafe storage practices in the home.
Among specific household products, hydrocarbon poisoning from unintentional ingestion of kerosene (paraffin) is widely reported as the most common cause of pediatric admissions in low-income countries around the world.41,45,96,102,173 Kerosene is a common fuel used to power stoves and lamps in many relatively poor communities. It is pale in color with an appearance similar to water, and it is often purchased or stored in used beverage containers making it easy to misidentify (Chap. 108).62 In Sub-Saharan Africa, kerosene poisoning accounts for some 25% to 75% of all poisoning-related hospital visits among children younger than 6 years of age.122 Several studies document an increase in poisoning related admissions during the warmer months of the year, when children are more likely to become thirsty and to drink from any beverage container at hand.101,102
Caustics are another group of household products frequently implicated in poisoning in the developing world. The common form of caustic ingested varies between countries. In many countries, alkaline substances are most frequently implicated, whereas in others, such as Taiwan and Morocco, poisoning with hydrochloric or sulfuric acids may be more common.3,105,154,180 Acute poisoning carries substantial mortality risk, usually more than 10%. If the acute phase of caustic poisoning is survived, there also is a high rate of delayed complications, primarily esophageal strictures. Delayed complications may require surgical intervention, balloon dilatation of the esophagus (bougienage), or feeding tube placement. These treatments are expensive, require significant hospital resources, and have inherent morbidity and mortality (Chap. 106).
As with other categories of poison, patterns of self-harm using domestic products tend to demonstrate regional particularities. For example, in Hong Kong there is significant morbidity reported in association with self-poisoning using common household detergent products such as dettol (4.8% chloroxylenol, pine oil, and isopropyl alcohol) and savlon (cetrimide).34,37,39,46 Frequent use of potassium permanganate for self-harm has also been reported from Hong Kong.129,181 Fatal poisoning with hair dye (paraphenylenediamine) is known in the Middle East and North Africa.29,61,80,151 Barium sulfide, arsenic sulfide, and calcium oxide are contained in hair removal preparations146; poisoning from ingestion of these preparations has been reported from India and Iran.4 Rubigine is a domestic cleansing product containing hydrofluoric acid and ammonium difluoride that is used for self-harm in the Caribbean,85 while ingestion of sodium hydroxide is common in Malaysia.19
Poisonous plants have been used therapeutically to induce abortion, for recreational intoxication, in homicidal acts, and for self-harm throughout human history (Chap. 121). This section briefly mentions select toxic plants that are most commonly used in self-poisoning, or that have caused epidemic poisoning in the developing world.
Self-poisoning with seeds of two plants containing cardioactive steroids are important clinical problems in Asia. Yellow oleander (Thevetia peruviana) kills hundreds of people each year in Sri Lanka and India28,57 (Chap. 65). Sea mango (Cerbera manghas) has killed hundreds of people in Kerala, India,68 and is a focal problem in eastern Sri Lanka.58 Oduvan (Cleistanthus collinus) leaf contains the glycosides cleistanthin A and B, which produce severe hypokalemia and cardiac dysrhythmias.13 Self-poisoning has killed hundreds of people in Tamil Nadu, India.12,155 The superb lily (Gloriosa superba) contains colchicine alkaloids and has also been used for self harm in South Asia5,9,111 (Chap. 36).
Ackee tree fruit (Blighia sapida), which contains hypoglycin when unripe, is widely consumed as a food source. Epidemics of fatal poisoning with unripe Ackee fruit have occurred throughout the Caribbean and in Africa.64,92,110,112 Poisoning by castor beans (Ricinus communis) or other lectin containing plants such as Jatropha spp (African purging nut) is well reported from Africa and South Asia1,65,78,93 (Chap. 121).
Numerous plant species contain atropine like alkaloids, causing an anticholinergic syndrome when ingested. Reports of intentional ingestion of Datura species have been reported from Africa, Asia, and Latin America.78,143,152 Most commonly, the seeds are ingested as a recreational drug for their hallucinatory effects,67,138 or as part of traditional medical preparations.35
Occupational and Environmental Sources
Poisoning from occupational and environmental sources is a significant global health problem, with disproportionate effects on persons living in lower income communities around the world. Exposure to “traditional” environmental health hazards, such as indoor air pollution from the combustion of solid fuels, and naturally occurring contaminants in groundwater, soil, and food, is still a major cause of morbidity and mortality in much of the world. Around 50% of the world’s people rely on solid fuels such as coal, dung, wood, or crop residues for cooking and heating.31 Resultant indoor air pollution was estimated to cause 1,965,000 deaths and 41,009,000 DALYs from lower respiratory tract infections, cancers, and COPD in 2004.178 In Bangladesh, arsenic contaminated groundwater contributed to 9100 deaths and 125,000 DALYs in 2001.107 Dental and skeletal fluorosis from excessive fluoride in drinking water is endemic in at least 17 countries worldwide.66
Increasingly, modern environmental health hazards (MEHHs) also play a large role in global poisoning risks.49,124 MEHHs include outdoor air pollution from automobiles and factories, soil and water contamination by plastics, heavy metals, pesticides and other industrial chemicals and wastes, radiation hazards, land degradation, and climate change produced by rapid urbanization and industrial development in the absence of strong regulatory controls.49 These are important sources of both occupational and environmental exposure to a wide range of toxins with acute and chronic health effects. Inadequate safeguards to control the selection, sale, and application of pesticides in parts of Africa and Asia are linked to pesticide poisoning both as an occupational hazard53,91 and from residues left on food.11,48,123 Occupational lead poisoning has largely been controlled in developed countries through improved working conditions and occupational health screens, but remains an enormous problem in developing countries where occupational and environmental health protection measures are often underdeveloped or practically nonexistent.164,171
Industrial factories are often placed in urban areas, or the areas around factories are rapidly urbanized, placing large numbers of people at risk not only from pollution but from industrial errors as well. The 1984 Bhopal tragedy in which a Union Carbide pesticide plant malfunctioned, releasing isocyanate gas into the surrounding community and causing an estimated 3787 deaths and 558,125 injuries, is emblematic of such disasters.14,145
Several international agreements on chemical safety provide legal frameworks to mitigate the human and environmental impact of global industrialization; however, the actual implementation of regulatory controls has lagged behind the expansion of toxic exposures. For example, at the level governance a total of 39 Sub-Saharan African countries have ratified the Rotterdam Convention on chemical safety. Yet industrial pollution is now becoming so highly concentrated in growing urban areas that the continent’s pollution intensity (pollution generated per unit of production output) is now rated among the world’s highest, attesting to significant regional difficulties in enforcing such regulations.166
The predominance of informal sector activity in agricultural and industrial work in lower income countries poses serious regulatory challenges. Fumes and dusts from small-scale domestic businesses involved in smelting, battery recycling or manufacture, welding, pottery, ceramic production, and artisanal mining are common sources of exposure to lead and other heavy metals in developing countries, and put not only workers but whole communities at risk.164 More recently, unregulated electronic waste (e-waste) recycling, in which salable metals are reclaimed from old electronics by burning, has emerged as a significant human and environmental health hazard in parts of China, West Africa, and India.7,104,160 Workers are often aware of the health risks, yet economic hardship and lack of alternative employment make them unwilling or unable to change.
Easy access to industrial chemicals from inadequate regulation of packaging and sales may also facilitate their use for intentional self-harm. For example, formic and acetic acids are used in the manufacture of rubber, and case series are reported from areas surrounding rubber factories in India and Sri Lanka.139 Copper sulfate is widely used for self-poisoning in parts of South Asia, and carries a high mortality rate due to direct damage to the gastrointestinal tract, hepatorenal failure, and hemolysis6,144 (Chap. 95). Cyanide has become a commonly used method in Korea over the last 20 years106 (Chap. 126).
REDUCING THE GLOBAL IMPACT OF POISONING
Regulatory science and the coordinated actions of agencies and programs across multiple sectors play a vital role in preventing or reducing the impact of poisoning in society. Within the health sector, significant inter- and intraregional disparities in access to health care have a major impact on poisoning outcomes. Lack of human resources to provide acute care is an enormous problem in many parts of the developing world. In Mozambique, there is only one trained medical doctor for every 33,000 individuals, compared with 1 in 390 persons in the United States. Tanzania has a nurse to population ratio of 1:2700 individuals compared with 1:107 individuals in the United States. Policies and programs encouraging sustainable and equitable health workforce development are needed foundation to improve health care access globally.50
Beyond rectifying the raw numbers deficit, clinical training programs in many low and middle income countries must be upgraded to promote broad exposure and specialist development in clinical toxicology and acute care. Increasing local and international commitment to the growth of emergency medicine in low- and middle-income countries promises to support the dissemination of scientific knowledge and improve provider competence in advanced resuscitation techniques.8,16,70 Significant gaps in infrastructure and resources to provide basic critical care interventions and meet WHO minimum standards for essential emergency supplies must also be addressed.17,18,83
In addition to global disparities in acute care infrastructure generally, access to antidotes for specific poisons is either lacking or inadequate in much of the world.10,131,176 Poor antidote availability is not unique to the developing world,51 and many antidotes may be considered either adjunctive or unnecessary therapies. However, in certain cases they can significantly reduce the need for other medical interventions, and this may be particularly important in rural or underdeveloped areas where critical care facilities are not readily available.134 For example, the most important challenge to improving the treatment of patients with snakebite worldwide is poor antivenom availability, particularly in rural areas where it is most needed to reduce critical delays in administration.162,163 Currently, many available antivenoms are prohibitively expensive, ineffective, or have a high rate of adverse reactions. Equally important, some antivenoms must be refrigerated, making storage impractical in many rural areas where the need is most acute. Critical evaluation of existing antivenoms and development of new products are thus desperately needed24,30,76,77,105,162,163,172,175 (Special Considerations: SC8).
Where antidotes are available, knowledge and experience to know how to use them safely and effectively is often lacking.32 Input from experts in medical toxicology improves outcomes, reduces hospital stays and health care costs associated with acute poisoning,33,47,69 but practitioners in many parts of the world have limited or no access to consultation with such specialists. The mission of the International Union of Toxicology is to foster international scientific cooperation, ensure the development of toxicologists, and promote the dissemination of knowledge in toxicology worldwide.55 Through the collaborative efforts of this and other regional professional societies, an increasing number of online, regional, and international forums now offer educational and professional development opportunities in clinical toxicology around the globe. More work is needed to promote awareness and the growth of the specialty in all regions.
Improving health care access and health system preparedness is only one aspect of the coordinated, multilevel, national, and international public health responses needed to reduce the global impact of poisoning. Prevention and risk reduction efforts must involve locally appropriate community level education and awareness raising, strong governance to support the design, implementation, and monitoring of regulatory controls, and the involvement of multiple stakeholders and sectors including water, waste management, energy, agriculture, transportation, industry, and civil society. Effective legislative frameworks developed in countries with more advanced public health infrastructure have been successfully disseminated in some cases. For example, between 2000 and 2004 the proportion of people with blood lead concentrations above 10 μg/dL globally decreased from 20% to 14%, largely due to the widespread phase out of leaded gasoline.135 Other strategies, such as pharmaceutical and food safety regulations enacted through the US Food and Drug Administration, have influenced “duplicative legislation” in other countries but continue to pose significant implementation challenges in low and middle income countries that lack the necessary financing, human resources, and infrastructure to enforce them well.130
Many public health measures with proven efficacy, such as routine lead testing during childhood, the regulation of vehicle emissions, the detection of carbon monoxide, and the incorporation of childproof containers may seem prohibitively resource intensive in many parts of the world. The development of new, low-cost technologies such as solar heating and electrical sources, chemical assays and residue detectors, and electronic devices to identify and track pharmaceuticals hold some promise to reduce global risks for unintentional poisoning. More research is needed to propose and evaluate the effectiveness, acceptability, and sustainability of new and proven poison prevention techniques in resource-limited environments.
Recognizing that self-harm from pesticide ingestion is responsible for a majority of acute poisoning deaths worldwide, public health interventions specifically designed to limit access are an important goal. A minimum pesticide list, based on the WHO essential xenobiotic list initiative, has been proposed.59 Such a list would provide policy makers and farmers with unbiased information about relative risks. However, voluntary initiatives such as international policy statements and industry sponsored programs often suffer from a lack of resources, a shortage of political will, and nonexistent enforcement mechanisms.100,115 A dramatic illustration of an effective national program to reduce pesticide poisoning risks is the ban of all WHO high-risk OP insecticides and the organic chlorine endosulfan in Sri Lanka, which effectively arrested a previously exponential increase in the incidence of pesticide poisoning and halved the national suicide rate between 1995 and 2005.73 This program is estimated to have saved more than 20,000 lives in 10 years.73
Ironically, some programs to remove the most environmentally persistent and toxic chemicals from use have inadvertently replaced them with agents highly toxic to humans. The replacement of persistent organic chlorine compounds with carbamates in malaria control programs is an example. The opposite effect has also occurred, for example, by replacing OP insecticides with pyrethroids to reduce human toxicity.100 Coordinated pesticide harm reduction strategies should take into account concerns regarding both environmental and human toxicity, and anticipate which xenobiotics will enter into use as replacements as specific chemicals are phased out.141 A strategy based on industrial hygiene models of a hierarchy of controls has been proposed by several authors115,141
TABLE 137–2.Hierarchical Strategies to Reduce Pesticide Poisoning Mortality in the Developing World108 |Favorite Table|Download (.pdf) TABLE 137–2. Hierarchical Strategies to Reduce Pesticide Poisoning Mortality in the Developing World108
|E ||Most ||Eliminate the most highly toxic pesticides |
|F || ||Substitute with less toxic, equally effective alternatives |
|F || ||Reduce use through improved equipment |
|I || ||Isolate people from the hazard |
|C || || |
|A || ||Label products and train applicators in safe handling practices |
|C || ||Promote use of personal protection equipment |
|Y || ||Institute administrative controls |
Poisoning is a common worldwide. Fatal poisoning is disproportionately concentrated in lower and middle income countries, where public health systems and acute care resources to detect, manage, prevent, and collect data on poisoning are often less well developed.
Global poisoning estimates are mostly derived from health care sources in a minority of developing world countries; current data may underrepresent the true burden and distribution of injuries from poisoning.
Efforts to develop international poisoning surveillance systems and establish harmonized definitions of poisoning cases will help generate a more complete picture to inform local, national, and international policies and interventions.
Pesticides are the most important cause of death from acute poisoning worldwide, with a majority of cases attributable to acts of deliberate self harm.
Improving access to health care and health system preparedness to provide acute care is essential to reduce global disparities in poisoning outcomes.
Randomized controlled trials and cost effectiveness research are needed to critically evaluate the utility of specific public health and treatment interventions in resource limited settings.
Michael Eddleston, MD, and Aaron Hexdall, MD, contributed to this chapter in previous editions.
SR: Acute toxicity studies with Jatropha curcas L. Hum Toxicol.
D: Psychological autopsy study of suicide in three rural and semi-rural districts of Sri Lanka. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol.
F, El Fares
F, El Moussaoui
et al.: Les lesions caustiques du tractus digestif superieur. A propos de 191 observations. J Chir (Paris).
NK: Barium sulfide poisoning. J Assoc Physicians India.
HA: Acute ascending polyneuropathy and dermatitis following poisoning by tubers of Gloriosa superba. Ceylon Med J. 1971;233–234.
sulphate poisoning. Trop Doct.
et al.: Comparative evaluation of environmental contamination and DNA damage induced by electronic-waste in Nigeria and China. Sci Total Environ.
CJ: History of the development of international emergency medicine. Emerg Med Clin N Am.
HM: Gloriosa superba poisoning. J Assoc Physicians India.
et al.: Evaluate the impact of hospital types on the availability of antidotes for the management of acute toxic exposures and poisonings in Malaysia. Hum Exp Toxicol.
et al.: Pesticide and pathogen contamination of vegetables in Ghana’s urban markets. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol.
C, Chandra Sekharan
P: A promising antidote to Cleistanthus collinus poisoning. J Forensic Sci Soc India. 1986;2:3–6.
et al.: Spectrofluorometric determination of the toxic constituents of Cleistanthus collinus. J Anal Toxicol.
[Anonymous]: Calamity at Bhopal. Lancet. 1984;2:1378–1379.
S: Contaminated drugs are held responsible for 120 deaths in Pakistan. BMJ.
JL: International emergency medicine and the recent development of emergency medicine worldwide. Ann Emerg Med.
et al.: Availability of decontamination, elimination enhancement, and stabilization resources for the management of acute toxic exposures and poisonings in emergency departments in Malaysia. Intern Emerg Med.
et al.: Availability of critical care resources to treat patients with severe sepsis or septic shock in Africa: a self-reported, continent-wide survey of anesthesia providers. Crit Care. 2001;15:1–12.
M: Early management of corrosive burns of the oesophagus. Br J Surg.
et al.: The changing trends of childhood poisoning at a tertiary children’s hospital in South Africa. SAMJ. 2012;102:142–146.
et al.: Identification and quantification of diethylene glycol in pharmaceuticals implicated in poisoning epidemics: an historical laboratory perspective. J Anal Toxicol.
K: Anti-malarial drug quality in Lagos and Accra—a comparison of various quality assessments. Malar J.
HS: Snake venoms and antivenoms: critical supply issues. J Assoc Physicians India.
D: Deaths from pesticide poisoning: a global response. Brit J Psychiat.
et al.: A clinical decision aid for triage of children younger than 5 years and with organophosphate or carbamate insecticide exposure in developing countries. Ann Emerg Med.
E: L’intoxication a la chloroquine
au C.H.S.Abidjan. Afr Med.
et al.: Cardiovascular effects of yellow oleander ingestion. J Indian Med Assoc.
D: Toxicite systemique de la paraphenylene diamine. Quatre observations. Presse Med.
NI: Consequences of neglect: analysis of the sub-Saharan African snake antivenom markget and the global context. PLoS Negl Trop Dis.
R: Air pollution in developing countries: a major environmental and public health challenge. Bull World Health Org. 2000;78:1078–1092.
et al.: Where is the evidence for the management of pesticide poisoning—is clinical toxicology fiddling while the developing world burns?J Toxicol Clin Toxicol.
et al.: The effect of poison control center consultation on accidental poisoning inpatient hospitalizations with preexisting medical conditions. J Toxicol Environ Health A.
TY: Anticholinergic poisoning due to Chinese herbal medicines. Vet Hum Toxicol.
JA: Usage and adverse effects of Chinese herbal medicines. Hum Exp Toxicol.
JT: The risk of aspiration in Dettol poisoning: a retrospective cohort study. Hum Exp Toxicol.
JA: Poisoning due to Chinese proprietary medicines. Hum Exp Toxicol.
JAJH: Poisoning due to common household products. Singapore Med J.
A: An outbreak of Heliotrope food poisoning, Tadjikistan, November 1992-March 1993. Sante.
EM: Childhood poisoning at the Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, Balatyre, Malawi. East African Med J.
JP: Snake-bites: appraisal of the global situation. Bull World Health Organ.
JP: Snake bite epidemiology in Benin. Bull Soc Pathol Exot.
M: Epidemiology of scorpionism: a global appraisal. Acta Trop.
I: Acute poisoning in a paediatric intensive care unit in Harare. Cent Afr J Med.
FL: Attempted suicide in children and adolescents in Hong Kong. Soc Psychiatry.
et al.: Resource-use analysis of a medical toxicology consultation service. Ann Emerg Med.
et al.: The problems associated with pesticide use by irrigation workers in Ghana. Occup Med.
KR: Health, environment and sustainable development: identifying links and indicators to promote action. Epidemiology.
N: Turning the World Upside Down: The Search for Global Health in the 21st Century. London: Royal Society of Medicine Press Ltd; 2010.
A: Healer shopping in Africa: new evidence from rural-urban qualitative study of Ghanaian diabetes experiences. BMJ.
AR: Toxicity due to organophosphorus compounds: what about chronic exposure?Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
et al.: Mass ethion poisoning with high mortality. Clin Toxicol.
et al.: Past challenges faced: an overview of current educational activities of IUTOX. Tox Appl Pharmacol.
M: Patterns and problems of deliberate self-poisoning in the developing world. QJM.
et al.: Epidemic of self-poisoning with seeds of the yellow oleander tree (Thevetia peruviana) in northern Sri Lanka. Trop Med Int Health.
S: Fatal injury in eastern Sri Lanka, with special reference to cardenolide self-poisoning with Cerbera manghas fruits. Clin Toxicol.
et al.: Pesticide poisoning in the developing world—a minimum pesticides list. Lancet.
K: Deliberate self-harm in Sri Lanka: an overlooked tragedy in the developing world. BMJ.
HW: Systemic toxicity of para-phenylenediamine. Lancet.
et al.: Paraffin ingestion—the problem. S Afr Med J.
E: Toxic heavy metals and undeclared drugs in Asian herbal medicines. Trends Pharmacol Sci.
SE: Fatal poisoning in Jamaica: a coroner’s autopsy study from the University Hospital of the West Indies. Med Sci Law.
D: Poisoning with plants and mushrooms in Sri Lanka: a retrospective hospital based study. Vet Hum Toxicol.
J: An attempt to estimate the global burden of disease due to fluoride in drinking water. J Water Health.
CF: Angel trumpet lily poisoning in five adolescents: clinical findings and management. J Paediatr Child Health.
F: Cerbera odollam: a ‘suicide tree’ and cause of death in the state of Kerala, India. J Ethnopharmacol.
et al.: Impact of a poison control center on the length of hospital stay of poisoned patients: retrospective cohort. Sao Paulo Med J.
Global Emergency Medicine Literature Review Group: Global emergency medicine: a review of the literature from 2011. Acad Emerg Med.
et al.: Ethnopharmacological survey of six medicinal plants from Mali, West-Africa. J Ethnobiol Ethnomed.
F: The global distribution of fatal pesticide self-poisoning: systematic review. BMC Public Health.
M: The impact of pesticide regulations on suicide in Sri Lanka. Int J Epidemiol.
SK: Aluminium phosphide poisoning—a review. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol.
S: Misuse of corticosteroids in some of the drugs dispensed as preparations from alternative systems of medicine in India. Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf.
JM: Improving antivenom availability and accessibility: Science, technology, and beyond. Toxicon.
DA: Confronting the neglected problem of snake bit envenoming: the need for a global partnership. PLoS Med.
et al.: Plant poisonings from herbal medicines admitted to a Tunisian toxicological intensive care unit, 1983-1998. Vet Hum Toxicol.
et al.: Fatal renal failure caused by diethylene glycol in paracetamol elixir: the Bangladesh epidemic. BMJ.
et al.: Poisoning from henna dye and para-phenylenediamine mixtures in children in Khartoum. Ann Trop Paediatr.
M: International perspectives in medical toxicology. In: Goldfrank’s Toxicologic Emergencies.8th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 2006:1832–1846.
TF: Snakebites in children in the densely populated city of Hong Kong: a 10-year survey. Acta Paediatr.
et al.: Access to emergency and surgical care in sub-Saharan Africa: the infrastructure gap. Health Policy Plan.
ML: Adulteration by synthetic therapeutic substances of traditional Chinese medicines in Taiwan. J Clin Pharmacol.
JM: Les intoxications volontaires dans l’ile de Cayenne en 1979, 1980 et 1981. Med d’Afrique Noire. 1983;30:267–271.
et al.: The prevalence of traditional herbal medicine use among hypertensives living in South African communities. Compl Alt Med.
JR: Melamine and the global implications of food contamination. N Engl J Med.
D: Antivenom treatment in arachnidism. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol.
MK: Changing trends of poisoning at railway stations. J Assoc Physicians India.
J: Acute pesticide poisoning: a major global health problem. World Health Stat Q.
WO: Survey of acute pesticide poisoning among agricultural workers in four Asian countries. Bull World Health Organ.
et al.: Ackee fruit poisoning: an outbreak investigation in Haiti 2000-2001, and review of the literature. Clin Toxicol (Phila).
PD: Acute poisoning with Jatropha curcas (purging nut tree) in children. S Afr Med J.
L: Acute poisoning in developing countries. Adverse Drug React Acute Poisoning Rev.
CF: The pattern of poisoning from traditional medicines in urban Zimbabwe. S Afr Med J.
CFB: A pattern of acute poisoning in children in urban Zimbabwe: ten years experience. Hum Exp Toxicol.
AR, De Silva
et al.: The global burden of snakebite: a literature analysis and modelling based on regional estimates of envenoming and deaths. PLoS Med.
N, al Haque
N: Poisoning in a medical unit of Dhaka Medical College Hospital in 1983. Bangladesh Med J. 1985;14:9–12.
D: Pesticide self-poisoning: thinking outside the box. Lancet.
F, van der Hoek
et al.: Reducing acute poisoning in developing countries—options for restricting the availability of pesticides. Toxicology.
MH: The epidemiology of accidental poisoning in children. S Afr Med J.
et al.: Les intoxications aigues accidentelles de l’enfant: aspects epidemiologiques, etiologiques et evolutifs au CHU pediatrique Charles-de-Gaulle de Ouagadougou (Burkina Faso). Cahiers Sante. 2009;19:55–59.
SAM: Common krait (Bungarus caeruleus) bite in Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka: a prospective clinical study, 1996-98. Postgrad Med J.
JJ: Analysis of suicide in legal autopsy during the period of 1981-1984. Seoul J Med. 1985;26:325–330.
AH: The effect of arsenic mitigation interventions on disease burden in Bangladesh. Environ Health Perspect.
et al.: Criminal poisoning of commuters in Bangladesh: prospective and retrospective study. Forensic Sci Int.
et al.: Cardiac glycoside poisoning involved in deaths from traditional medicines. S Afr Med J.
et al.: Epidemic of fatal encephalopathy in preschool children in Burkino Faso and consumption of unripe ackee (Blighia sapida) fruit. Lancet.
J: Ackee (Blighia sapida) poisoning in the Northern Province, Haiti, 2001. Epidemiol Bull.
AD: Mortality by cause for eight regions of the world: Global Burden of Disease Study. Lancet.
AD: Alternative projections of mortality and disability by cause 1990-2020: Global Burden of Disease Study. Lancet.
PL: Claim no easy victories: evaluating the pesticide industry’s Global Safe Use campaign. World Dev.
et al.: A propos de 286 intoxications a la chloroquine
. Afr Med.
A: Watch out for a friendly stranger at railway station. Indian Express. April 6, 1999.
et al.: Poor-quality antimalarial drugs in southeast Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. Lancet.
FM: Impact of poor-quality medicines in the ‘developing’ world. Trends Pharmacol Sci.
et al.: Aspects of orthodox medicines (therapeutic drugs) poisoning in urban Zimbabwe. Hum Exp Toxicol.
OMJ: The pattern of poisoning in urban Zimbabwe. J Appl Toxicol.
OMJ: Household chemical poisoning admissions in Zimbabwe’s main urban centres. Hum Exp Toxicol.
WJ: Organochlorine pesticides in water, sediment, crops, and human fluids in a farming community in Ghana. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol.
WH: Modern environmental health hazards: a public health issue of increasing significance in Africa. Environ Health Perspect.
IM: Pattern of hospital admissions of children with poisoning in the Sudano-Sahelian North Eastern Nigeria. Nigerian J Clin Pract. 2007;10:111–115.
et al.: Diethylene glycol poisoning in Nigerian children. Ann Trop Paediatr.
FT: Evaluation of use of herbal medicines among ambulatory hypertensive patients attending a secondary health care facility in Nigeria. Int J Pharm Pract.
WL: Potassium permanganate poisoning—a rare cause of fatal self poisoning. J Accident Emerg Med.
MA: Impact of regulatory science on global public health. Kaohsiung J Med Sci.
AM: Availability of antidotes in hospital pharmacies in Greece. Vet Human Toxicol. 2001;43:103–105.
Press Trust of India: Inter-state gang involved in train robbery busted. Indian Express. August 1, 1999.
Pronczuk de Garbino
T: Evaluation of antidotes: activities of the International Programme on Chemical Safety. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol.
et al.: Knowns and unknowns on burden of disease due to chemicals: a systematic review. Environ Health.
RD: Incidence and mortality on snake bite in savanna Nigeria. Lancet.
RJ: The rising incidence of serious chloroquine
overdose in Harare, Zimbabwe: emergency department surveillance in the developing world. Trop Doct.
JS: Poisoning due to ingestion of the seeds of kechubong (Datura fastuosa) for its ganja-like effect in Singapore. J Trop Med Hyg.
SK: Formic acid poisoning with suicidal intent: a report of 53 cases. Postgrad Med J.
et al.: Outbreak of acute renal failure in Panama in 2006: a case-control study. Bull World Health Organ.
et al.: Influence of pesticide regulation on acute poisoning deaths in Sri Lanka. Bull World Health Organ.
M: Unintentional childhood injuries in sub-Saharan Africa: an overview of risk and protective factors. J Health Care Poor Underserved.
HT: Jimson weed food poisoning. An epidemic at Usangi rural government hospital. Trop Geogr Med.
et al.: Acute ingestion of copper
sulphate: a review of its clinical manifestations and management. Ind J Crit Care Med.
et al.: Impact of snake bites and determinants of fatal outcomes in southeastern Nepal. Am J Trop Med Hyg.
et al.: Diethylene glycol poisoning in Gurgaon, India, 1998. Bull World Health Organ.
AP: Arsenic in the environment: effects on human health and possible prevention. J Environ Biol.
et al.: The prevalence and morbidity of snake bite and treatment-seeking behaviour among a rural Kenyan population. Ann Trop Med Parasitol.
RC: Hair dye poisoning. J Assoc Physicians India.
SK: An epidemiological study of poisoning cases reported to the National Poisons Information Centre, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi. Hum Exp Toxicol.
M: The toxicology of African herbal remedies. Ther Drug Monitor.
WH: Management for acute corrosive injury of upper gastrointestinal tract. Chinese Med J. 1994;54:20–25.
B: A clinical and laboratory profile of Cleistanthus collinus poisoning. J Assoc Physicians India.
CFB: Differences and similarities in poisoning admissions between urban and rural health centers in Zimbabawe. Clin Tox.
CFB: Traditional medicine poisoning in Zimbabwe: clinical presentation and management in adults. Hum Exp Toxicol.
YT: Intentional overdosage with isoniazid
: case report and review of the literature. Singapore Med J.
CA: Acute isoniazid
poisoning: a case report and review of the literature. Bangladesh Med J.
et al.: Heavy metal and persistent organic contamination in soil from Wenling: an emerging e-waste recycling city in Taizhou area, China. J Hazard Mater.
et al.: Pharmacopoeial quality of drugs supplied by Nigerian pharmacists. Lancet.
E: Report of a WHO workshop on the standardization and control of antivenoms. Toxicon.
S, von Schrnding
T: Environmental lead exposure: a public health problem of global dimensions. Bull World Health Organ. 200;78:1068–1077.
P: A case of dapsone
poisoning: toxicological data and review of the literature. J Anal Toxicol.
UNIDO: The Industrial Development Report 2004. Industrialization, Environment and the Millenium Development Goals in Sub-Saharan Africa: The New Frontier in the Fight against Poverty. Vienna: United Nations Industrial Development Organization; 2004.
PH: Aspects of poisoning with traditional medicines in southern Africa. Biomed Environ Sci.
DW: Protocol and monitoring to improve snake bite outcomes in rural Ghana. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
DA: Venomous bites and stings in the tropical world. Med J Aust.
CG: Bites by the Philippine cobra (Naja naja philippinensis): an important cause of death among rice farmers. Am J Trop Med Hyg.
et al.: Clinical toxinology—where are we now?J Toxicol Clin Toxicol.
WHO EMRO Pediatric Hydrocarbon Study Group, Cairo, Egypt, Bond
et al.: A clinical decision rule for triage of children under 5 years of age with hydrocarbon (kerosene) aspiration in developing countries. Clin Toxicol.
et al.: The Global Snakebite Initiative: an antidote for snakebite. Lancet.
BA: Antidotes and their availability in South Africa. Clin Tox.
World Health Organization: The Global Burden of Disease; 2004 Update. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2008.
WW: Surgical management of extensive corrosive injuries of the alimentary tract. Surg Gynecol Obstet.
et al.: Fatal acute hepatorenal failure following potassium permanganate ingestion. Hum Exp Toxicol.